2nd Degree Murder in FL: How Long Will They REALLY Serve?

Florida law defines second-degree murder as an unlawful killing with depraved indifference. The Florida Department of Corrections manages individuals incarcerated for this offense, which significantly impacts 2nd degree murders sentences in florida. Understanding the legal definition provided by Florida Statutes is crucial when analyzing these cases. The severity of the crime leads to varied sentences, influencing the actual time served due to factors like good behavior and plea bargains. Therefore, determining how long someone will truly serve for 2nd degree murders sentences in florida requires a nuanced understanding of these interacting elements.

Image taken from the YouTube channel Grey Tesh , from the video titled Difference 1st degree murder and 2nd degree Murder in Florida (lawyer) .

Understanding 2nd Degree Murder Sentences in Florida

The severity of penalties for 2nd degree murder in Florida makes it crucial to understand the legal nuances involved. This explanation breaks down what factors influence the actual time served after a conviction.

Defining 2nd Degree Murder in Florida

Before delving into sentencing, it's important to define what constitutes 2nd degree murder under Florida law. It's not premeditated (like 1st degree murder), but it isn't accidental (like manslaughter).

• Key Element: 2nd degree murder typically involves an intentional act that is imminently dangerous to another and demonstrates a depraved mind, regardless of human life.

• Distinction from 1st Degree: The absence of premeditation is the key difference. It's often a crime of passion or reckless disregard rather than planned malice.

The Potential Maximum Sentence

The most significant piece of information is the potential penalty. While the potential sentence is significant, the actual time served can vary greatly.

• Maximum Sentence: Under Florida Statutes, 2nd degree murder is a first-degree felony punishable by a term of imprisonment for a term of years not exceeding life.

  • This means a judge could sentence someone to life in prison.
  • However, this is generally reserved for cases with aggravating circumstances.

Factors Influencing Actual Time Served

Several factors determine the actual time served, moving beyond the maximum sentence.

Florida’s Sentencing Guidelines

Florida operates with sentencing guidelines that judges use to determine appropriate sentences. These guidelines calculate a "score" based on the crime and the offender's criminal history.

• Primary Purpose: To ensure consistency and fairness in sentencing across the state.
• Score Calculation:
  1. Crime Severity: Points are assigned based on the severity level of the offense.
  2. Prior Record: Points are added for any prior convictions, including misdemeanors and felonies.
  3. Victim Injury: Additional points may be added based on the severity of the victim's injuries or death.

The 85% Rule ("Truth in Sentencing")

Florida has a "truth in sentencing" law, often referred to as the 85% rule. This rule significantly impacts the amount of time an individual must serve before becoming eligible for release.

• Mandatory Minimum: Individuals convicted of 2nd degree murder are required to serve at least 85% of their imposed sentence before becoming eligible for any form of early release (e.g., parole).

• Impact: This substantially reduces the possibility of serving a shorter sentence than what was initially imposed by the judge.

  • For example, a 20-year sentence means at least 17 years must be served.

Mitigating and Aggravating Circumstances

While the sentencing guidelines provide a framework, judges can consider mitigating and aggravating circumstances that can influence the length of the sentence.

• Mitigating Factors: These are factors that lessen the severity of the crime or the defendant's culpability. Examples include:

  • Lack of prior criminal history.
  • Demonstrating remorse.
  • The victim's conduct contributed to the offense.
  • The defendant's age or mental state at the time of the offense.

• Aggravating Factors: These are factors that increase the severity of the crime or the defendant's culpability. Examples include:

  • Extreme cruelty in the commission of the crime.
  • The crime was committed in the presence of a minor.
  • The defendant has a history of violent offenses.
  • The victim was particularly vulnerable.

Plea Bargaining

Plea bargaining is a common practice in the Florida criminal justice system. It can significantly impact the ultimate sentence.

• Negotiation: The prosecution and defense may negotiate a plea agreement where the defendant pleads guilty to a lesser charge (e.g., manslaughter) in exchange for a reduced sentence.

• Impact on Sentence: A successful plea bargain can result in a substantially shorter sentence than what would have been imposed after a conviction for 2nd degree murder at trial.

  You also like

  Lost Tree Club Florida: Your Ultimate Guide (You Won't Believe!)

Gain-Time

While the 85% rule severely limits early release, "gain-time" can potentially slightly reduce the time served, although its impact is often minimal in cases involving serious felonies like 2nd degree murder.

• Types of Gain-Time: Gain-time can be awarded for good behavior, participation in rehabilitative programs, or performing work assignments.

• Limited Applicability: Due to the severity of the crime and the 85% rule, the amount of gain-time available is often negligible, and it rarely results in a significant reduction in the actual time served.

Example Scenario Illustrating Sentence Variation

Video: 2nd Degree Murder in FL: How Long Will They REALLY Serve?

Play Video